drought fallacy in the West … science questioned

Scaremongering about drought is just the latest Astroscience from the usual scaremongers and pocket-liners. This position is now being questioned. Drought science questioned by leading climate scientists

Note the picture is from the Eastern States.

drought“The calculations that have all been done assumed that the only thing that controls how hard the atmosphere sucks water up is the temperature of the air, and that’s not true.”—Prof Roderick. Image: Hume Lake in VIC, Tim KeeganWHILE drought in WA’s south-west continues to worsen, a new analysis of global drought shows that, worldwide, the problem has been overestimated for decades.

Three of the world’s leading drought experts this month published a paper in the peer-reviewed journal Nature, showing that reports of more intense, longer droughts since the 1970s are incorrect.  

The scientists, including Australian Research Council’s Michael Roderick of the Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science, found that historical modelling calculations were too simplistic and ignored important factors that contribute to drought.

 “We show that the previously reported increase in global drought is overestimated because the Palmer Drought Severity Index uses a simplified model of potential that responds only to changes in temperature, and thus responds incorrectly to global warming in recent decades,” Associate Professor Roderick says.  

“The calculations that have all been done assumed that the only thing that controls how hard the atmosphere sucks water up is the temperature of the air, and that’s not true.”  

“More realistic calculations, based on the underlying physical principles that take into account changes in available energy, humidity and wind speed, suggest that there has been little change in drought over the past 60 years,” the scientists report in Nature.  

Prof Roderick says that while the south-west pocket of WA—as far north as Geraldton—continues to dry, the rest of WA, including its deserts, is getting wetter.  

“The trend in wetness there [in the desert] is one of the biggest in the world,” he says.

“The drying in the south-west [pocket] is not big by world standards.”  

Prof Roderick and his team found that some areas had suffered more drought since the 1950s, such as sub-Saharan Africa. But in other areas, the amount of drought has declined or stayed constant.   

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), consisting of hundreds of the world’s best climate scientists, originally used the Palmer Drought Severity Index in its Fourth Assessment Report (AR4).

The IPCC has since documented its over-reliance on the PDSI in regard to drought.  

University of Leeds climate change professor Piers Forster has backed the Roderick study and the IPCC’s AR4.  

“This study is a good example of the way scientists are continually questioning and refining our assessment of past and future climate changes.  

“This study in no way invalidates the overall conclusions of the IPCC AR4 study,” he says.

Prof Roderick says the relationship between climate change and drought is tenacious at best.

I note the discussion concerns Western Australia. The South West has just had record November and December rainfall.

Warwick Hughes has details and links to put them straight from a post some time ago.

2011 update 37 year Perth dams catchment rainfall trend – nearly a Thousand GL of water wasted over 15 years by not managing catchments

January 1st, 2012 by Warwick Hughes

In 2011 the Perth region has enjoyed an above average rain year – as shown in my graphic of 37 years of Perth dams catchment region May-October rainfall.
37 years of Perth dams rain
This second graphic shows the constant decline in “catchment efficiency” CE since the late 1990′s – which was about the last time water authorities did much to control understorey regrowth in catchments which drastically cuts back inflows to streams. A calculation for each of the last 15 years – assuming that a CE of 5.6% could easily be achieved without harming wildlife values – shows that a total of 998GL has been lost from 1997-2011. I have not costed this – but the extra 66GL PA would have made it unnecessary to embrace seawater desalination in such a rush.
2010 update 36 year Perth dams catchment rainfall trend
Stunning ignorance and lies surround Perth water supply policies
2009 update – Perth dam catchments rainfall still normal, Govt building $Billion seawater desalination plant #2
There never was a rain shortage to justify seawater desalination for Perth’s water supply

About Tom Harley

Amateur ecologist and horticulturalist and CEO of Kimberley Environmental Horticulture Inc.
This entry was posted in Climate, science, weather and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to drought fallacy in the West … science questioned

  1. I am Elohim your God. I shall speak of my die agnostic cull anal lysis of lies re guard Ing Drought water sourcing and the coming Great Flood. Rumors of drought in Texas are true, for they have mocked me and I shall make it a waste land where Cactus shall not grow. Drought in the West is temporary. 40 days of rain shall be a result of 4 meteors called the 4 horsemen who tow 10,000 city smashing meteors known as the Crusaders. Targeting is being done by the Demigods Jupiter and Aman who control Jupiter and the Sun. The Demigod Mars is helping but has little gravity in such matters as annihilation of Gog and Magog Genomes. Water shall be most abundant after the great flood and you have 14 gene rations to multiply and prosper and improve your intelligence by method of Eve-o-lute-of-Zion ( Evolution ). It is by intelligent design the small temporal droughts shall all be drowned and all land unter 300 feet elevation is known as MU ba sins are in basins there is enough water in caverns in limestone to supply 100 billion humans for 100 million years.
    When the meteor shower occurs on Nov 7, 2265, i shall cave in all caverns on Earth leaving some for select bats and fish to survive and some fresh water shrimps after their like and kind. Water shall well up from below when the caverns all cave in and half of Florida shall dis appear. There is a lost continent of mu that shall rise back up. On 2270 an ice age begins and total exodus from 10 northern nations shall begin. You shall hear rumors of droughts, but rejoice and multiply, for they are mostly not true. Disarm for nothing that is a weapon for killing your brother shall survive much longer. Mine under all military bases such as the platinum deposit between two gay armies in Korea. Mine under all prisons i have placed there gems as large as fists, silver, nickel, titanium, cobalt, and gold, I shall fill the dead sea and name it Great Lake of Fish. I shall fill Death Valley and name it Abundant Life Sea of Elohim. I shall sweep the Avenue of the Dead into the Sea, then plant a field of cherry blossoms. I am Elohim. If any man lacks water he is idle I gave you everything you shall ever want or need.

  2. Pingback: West Australian sea level BS … fact checking the gloom and doom with DATA | pindanpost

  3. Pingback: pocket-liner’s conference … South West Australia | pindanpost

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s