another model failure … deserts blooming

Australia’s deserts have never looked so good as the last couple of decades. Rainfall has increased, Lake Eyre has even filled several times in recent years, where it used to be once in a hundred.

Temperatures, on the other hand are mostly unchanged or with slight warming, except where BoM have made ‘adjustments’.

Which makes this article from a Fairfax ‘dead tree’ journal, ‘balderdash’:

Global warming: Australian deserts to expand as tropical circulation changes

John Ray at Greenie Watch adds: “Just modelling, which has so far always been wrong.”

Australia’s deserts will expand southward and dry periods will lengthen as global warming alters key tropical circulations, according to new research by US scientists.

The researchers studied how the Hadley Circulation – the movement of warm air and moisture away from the tropics – will be affected if carbon-dioxide emissions continue to rise at the rate of 1 per cent per year.

They found evidence* of a so-called “deep-tropics squeeze”, in which regions closest to the equator will experience increased convection as air rises faster.

Conversely, the drier sub-tropical regions characterised by descending air and resulting high-pressure systems will expand, according to the research published Tuesday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

“Our results provide a physical basis for inferring that greenhouse warming is likey to contribute to the observed prolonged droughts worldwide in recent decades,” the paper said.

Existing dry zones in Africa-Eurasia, south-west North America and much of Australia will face increased risk of drought, said William K.M. Lau, of the University of Maryland’s Earth System Science Interdisciplinary Centre, and co-author of the paper.

“As inferred from the model projections, the global warming effect on expansion of deserts is likely to be already going on,” Dr Lau told Fairfax Media.

The paper found that while some components of the Hadley Circulation will strengthen – resulting in increased rainfall in the deep tropics – ther elements will weaken. These findings will aid the understanding of the overall changes under way, he said.

“Detection of changes in the Hadley Circulation has been attempted by many previous authors, with no clear results whether it has strengthened, weakened or [had] no change,” he said.

Steve Turton, a climatologist at James Cook University, said the PNAS paper adds to other research indicating the tropical belt is expanding, such as signs that the location of the maximum intensity of cyclone is shifting poleward.

An intensification of deep tropical rainfall would mean more rainfall for regions to the north of Australia, such as Indonesia, Professor Turton said.

A further expansion of the high-pressure belt, on the other hand, means more rainfall missing mainland Australia, and falling in the Southern Ocean instead. “It spells a pretty grim forecast for Australia,” he said.

Rainfall is already on the decrease in southern Australia. Important winter rains over south-western WA have reduced by about a quarter since the 1970s, adding stresses to ecosystems and raising doubts about the prospects for wheat farming in the region, Professor Turton said.

Other regions reliant on monsoonal rains, such as the Indian sub-continent, will also likely see a disruption of rainfall patterns, he said.

My work often takes me to the Great Sandy Desert, but I am having problems finding the sand amongst the flora.

That’s despite the supposed increase in temperature. Even Africa’s deserts are blooming.


Craig Downer, Tanami Desert

Time to flog off the failed computers and go back to the field, like Ecologist Craig Downer and I.DSC00653Utter twaddle, says Warwick Hughes about the South West rainfall: ABC Catalyst TV show warped view of SW West Australian rainfall and this post, contradicting the models too: Research in progress suggests a link between salt levels in Antarctic ice cores and rain in south-west Western Australia.

*”They found evidence …”. Models are not evidence. There is so much that is wrong here.

About Tom Harley

Amateur ecologist and horticulturalist and CEO of Kimberley Environmental Horticulture Inc. (Tom Harley)
This entry was posted in Climate, comedy, Environment, media, science, weather and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to another model failure … deserts blooming

  1. Hi Tom, Qld, particularly the SEQ and NENSW are affected by a combination of SOI and PDO. Looking at the chart here it seems that we maybe getting back to a similar period from mid 1940’s to mid 1970’s which was a cooling period. Maybe a 60 year cycle but there maybe another longer cycle as indicated by reducing sunspots (two hundred year cycle). It appears that rainfall (and weather) in Western and Central Australia are affected by the Indian Ocean Dipole but there maybe some other affect such as the SOI.
    Searching on google shows some long term graphs but I can not find the source. This shows that the Indian ocean is not warm at present
    maybe you can find a graph that goes back to 1900 to see if there is a pattern

    • Tom Harley says:

      The Indian Ocean is very warm off the North West where I am, but a number of strong cyclones have travelled across the rest, cooling things somewhat. We are still awaiting our first of 4 predicted this season to cool us down. Last week we had about 4 minimums of 30C or more, a record according to BoM. Of course they missed January 1897 a 31.7C minimum, Feb 1903, 31.4C. Inconvenient, I guess.

  2. Pingback: climate change may shorten winter … or may not | pindanpost

  3. Pingback: These items caught my eye – 27 February 2015 | grumpydenier

  4. Old Cowhand says:

    In 1958 I first visited Wyndham WA and was told that, in a period in the early 50s the AIM Hospital had experienced temperatures which never dropped below 35C for ten days. I lived in and around Wyndham for 6 years but never stayed in the old town area but some three miles out which was some 3-5C lower but it was still very hot in and around the wet season. We were told that the old town had the second hottest mean temp in the world after Siera Leone and as a cargo handler in those days I can believe it.
    Such anecdotes may not be scientific but they sure give personal ammunition to climate sceptics like me

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s